Neighborhood Guide

Gutheil Gardens

Aurora, CO 80011

Data Verified: Jul 22, 2026

About this Area

Gutheil Gardens, situated in the northeastern part of Aurora, Colorado, is a neighborhood that beautifully marries historic charm with modern convenience, offering residents a unique blend of old-world character and contemporary living. Established in the early 1950s, Gutheil Gardens was originally developed as a post-war suburban community, and many of its original homes still stand today, showcasing classic mid-century architecture with brick facades, large picture windows, and expansive lots. The neighborhood's namesake, Gutheil Gardens, is a small but charming park that serves as a central gathering place for residents, featuring a playground, picnic areas, and walking paths that wind through lush greenery. Over the years, Gutheil Gardens has evolved into a diverse and welcoming community, where long-time residents and newcomers alike enjoy the neighborhood's peaceful atmosphere and strong sense of camaraderie. The tree-lined streets, adorned with mature elms and cottonwoods, create a serene backdrop for leisurely walks, while the neighborhood's proximity to major thoroughfares like I-225 ensures easy access to Denver and surrounding areas.

Gutheil Gardens features a dynamic real estate market with a median home value of $367,200, making it an attractive option for buyers seeking affordability without sacrificing quality or location. The neighborhood is characterized by a mix of original mid-century homes and newer infill properties, with architectural styles ranging from classic ranch homes to modern craftsman designs. Lot sizes typically range from 8,000 to 12,000 square feet, providing ample space for gardening, outdoor recreation, or future expansions. Many of the older homes in Gutheil Gardens have been lovingly renovated, featuring updated kitchens, bathrooms, and energy-efficient systems, while newer constructions offer open floor plans, high-end finishes, and smart home technology. The market here is competitive, with homes often selling quickly, but the neighborhood's reputation for stability and desirability ensures that buyers can find a property that meets their needs and budget.

Gutheil Gardens residents enjoy a wealth of amenities that cater to every aspect of daily life. The neighborhood is just a short drive from the bustling Aurora Town Center, which offers a variety of shopping options including Walmart, HomeGoods, and a wide selection of restaurants and entertainment venues. For outdoor enthusiasts, the nearby Sand Creek Regional Greenway Trail provides 14 miles of scenic pathways perfect for walking, biking, or jogging, while the Aurora Reservoir offers opportunities for fishing, boating, and picnicking. Families will appreciate the proximity to highly rated schools such as Aurora Hills Middle School and the innovative programs at Aurora Public Schools. Additionally, the neighborhood is served by the Fitzsimons Medical Campus, offering top-tier healthcare and employment opportunities. Local parks like Gutheil Gardens Park provide playgrounds, sports fields, and picnic areas for community gatherings, while the nearby Anschutz Medical Campus offers world-class healthcare and research facilities.

Gutheil Gardens is a prime choice for homebuyers seeking a neighborhood that offers historic charm, modern amenities, and economic stability, with a median household income of $69,719 ensuring a strong local economy. The neighborhood's strategic location provides easy access to major highways like I-225 and E-470, allowing for quick commutes to Denver International Airport in 25 minutes or downtown Denver in 30 minutes. Residents enjoy a high quality of life, with top-rated schools, premier healthcare facilities, and a variety of shopping and dining options close at hand. The community's well-maintained homes, lush landscaping, and strong sense of community contribute to its appeal, making it an ideal place for families, professionals, and retirees alike. Whether you're drawn to the historic charm of its mid-century homes or the modern appeal of newly renovated properties, Gutheil Gardens offers a lifestyle that is both enriching and rewarding.

Homendo Valuation Index
Quality of Life 88
Environment 94
Education 84
Safety 81
Demographics
Population
53,334
Density
3,400
Median Age
32.2
Income
$69,719
StatisticZipCityCountyStateUSA
Population 53,334 390,201655,7095,810,774332,387,540
Median Age 32.2 35.137.337.538.7
People per Household 2.87 2.712.562.452.54
Median Household Income $69,719 $84,320$97,215$92,470$78,538
Avg Income per Capita $30,227 $40,424$51,942$50,489$43,289
Real Estate Market
Median Value
$367,200
Median Rent
$1,438
Available
167
MetricZipCityCountyStateUSA
Median Sale Price$367,200$444,500$526,000$502,200$303,400
Median Age of Home4640403845
Homes Owned52.3%60.3%62.2%60.6%58.2%
Homes Rented44.3%35.0%33.3%30.8%31.3%
Homes Vacant3.4%4.7%4.5%8.6%10.4%
Quality of Life
IndexZipCityCountyStateUSA
Cost of Living Index108.4108.4108.4108.4100.0
Commute Time (min)29.428.927.325.526.6
Work from Home7.3%14.8%18.6%18.8%13.5%
Climate
Jan Low
19.8°
July High
90.4°
Rain
16.7"
MetricZipCityCountyStateUSA
Jan Avg Low (°F)19.819.819.819.819.8
July Avg High (°F)90.490.490.490.490.4
Annual Precip (in)16.716.716.716.716.7
Safety & Crime
Violent Crimes (per 100k)
TypeZipCityCountyStateUSA
Assault350.5350.5350.5350.5350.5
Murder4.54.54.54.54.5
Robbery63.063.063.063.063.0
Property Crimes (per 100k)
TypeZipCityCountyStateUSA
Burglary348.0348.0348.0348.0348.0
Theft1754.21754.21754.21754.21754.2

Neighborhood Insights

AI-Ready Analysis for Gutheil Gardens

Gutheil Gardens is an accessible entry-point into the CO real estate market located in Aurora. The neighborhood is offering a healthy balance of homeownership and rental opportunities..

Demographically, the area is popular among young professionals and growing families (Median Age: 32.2), creating a unique community atmosphere. With a median household income of $69,719, residents enjoy a quality of life that supports local commerce and community maintenance.
Source: Homendo Network Market Data Analysis (2026).

The real estate market in Gutheil Gardens is currently active. The median home value stands at $367,200, reflecting the desirability of the Aurora area. For investors or those looking to lease, the median rent is approximately $1,438.

According to Homendo Network, the area's inventory turnover (Vacancy Rate: 3.4%) suggests a competitive market where quality homes tend to sell quickly.
Source: Homendo Network Market Data Analysis (2026).

Gutheil Gardens holds a Homendo Safety Score of 81 and an Environmental Quality Score of 94. These metrics are calculated based on local crime statistics per 100k residents and environmental factors like air quality and park density.

Compared to the broader Aurora region, this neighborhood offers a specific balance of security and outdoor accessibility that appeals to safety-conscious buyers.
Source: Homendo Network Market Data Analysis (2026).

The educational landscape in Gutheil Gardens is rated at 84 on the Homendo Index. Located within the Arapahoe County jurisdiction, residents have access to a network of public and private institutions. Families often choose this area specifically for access to these educational resources.
Source: Homendo Network Market Data Analysis (2026).
Location
Powered By
Homendo Network

Real Estate Intelligence

For Professionals
Claim This Place ($1/mo)
WalkScore™
Walk
Car-Dependent
40
Transit
Good Transit
55
Bike
Somewhat Bikeable
45
School Ratings

Check rating and reviews of schools in this area.

View Schools