Neighborhood Guide

Tollgate Valley Gardens

Aurora, CO 80011

Data Verified: Jul 22, 2026

About this Area

Tollgate Valley Gardens in Aurora, Colorado, exudes a serene suburban charm with its well-manicured streets and a strong sense of community that has blossomed over the decades. Established in the late 1970s, this neighborhood has evolved into a sought-after residential enclave known for its family-friendly atmosphere and meticulously maintained homes. The area’s name pays homage to its historical roots, as it once served as a gateway to the broader Tollgate Valley region, a nod to the agricultural past of Aurora. Today, Tollgate Valley Gardens is celebrated for its peaceful ambiance, where residents enjoy tree-lined sidewalks, vibrant community events, and a tight-knit neighborhood feel that fosters lasting connections. The blend of mid-century modern and contemporary architectural styles adds to its timeless appeal, making it a perfect blend of nostalgia and modern living.

Tollgate Valley Gardens offers a diverse range of housing options, with a median home value of $367,200, reflecting its accessibility and desirability in Aurora’s competitive real estate market. The neighborhood predominantly features single-family homes built between the 1970s and 1990s, showcasing a variety of architectural styles from ranch-style bungalows to spacious two-story dwellings. Lot sizes typically range from 6,000 to 8,000 square feet, providing ample space for outdoor activities and gardening. Many homes have been updated with modern amenities while preserving their original character, making them highly attractive to both first-time buyers and long-term residents. The real estate market here is dynamic, with homes often selling within days of listing, underscoring the neighborhood’s strong demand.

Residents of Tollgate Valley Gardens enjoy unparalleled access to a wealth of local amenities that enhance their quality of life. The neighborhood is just a short drive from the bustling Aurora Mall, offering an array of shopping, dining, and entertainment options, including major retailers like Macy’s and Dick’s Sporting Goods. For outdoor enthusiasts, Tollgate Creek Trail provides a scenic 10-mile pathway perfect for walking, jogging, or biking, connecting to larger regional trails. Families appreciate the proximity to top-rated schools such as Aurora Public Schools’ Tollgate Elementary, which boasts a strong academic reputation and dedicated staff. Additionally, the neighborhood is within minutes of medical facilities like The Medical Center of Aurora, ensuring residents have quick access to healthcare services.

Tollgate Valley Gardens stands out as a premier choice for homebuyers seeking a balanced lifestyle in Aurora, thanks to its affordable median home value of $367,200 and a median household income of $69,719 that reflects economic stability. The neighborhood’s proximity to major highways like I-225 and E-470 ensures a straightforward commute to downtown Denver, Boulder, and other key employment hubs, with average commute times ranging from 20 to 35 minutes. Its family-friendly environment, coupled with excellent schools and abundant recreational opportunities, makes it an ideal place for raising children. The strong sense of community, combined with the convenience of nearby shopping and healthcare, further solidifies Tollgate Valley Gardens as a top-tier residential destination in Aurora.

Homendo Valuation Index
Quality of Life 92
Environment 90
Education 82
Safety 92
Demographics
Population
53,334
Density
3,200
Median Age
32.2
Income
$69,719
StatisticZipCityCountyStateUSA
Population 53,334 390,201655,7095,810,774332,387,540
Median Age 32.2 35.137.337.538.7
People per Household 2.87 2.712.562.452.54
Median Household Income $69,719 $84,320$97,215$92,470$78,538
Avg Income per Capita $30,227 $40,424$51,942$50,489$43,289
Real Estate Market
Median Value
$367,200
Median Rent
$1,438
Available
167
MetricZipCityCountyStateUSA
Median Sale Price$367,200$444,500$526,000$502,200$303,400
Median Age of Home4640403845
Homes Owned52.3%60.3%62.2%60.6%58.2%
Homes Rented44.3%35.0%33.3%30.8%31.3%
Homes Vacant3.4%4.7%4.5%8.6%10.4%
Quality of Life
IndexZipCityCountyStateUSA
Cost of Living Index108.4108.4108.4108.4100.0
Commute Time (min)29.428.927.325.526.6
Work from Home7.3%14.8%18.6%18.8%13.5%
Climate
Jan Low
19.8°
July High
90.4°
Rain
16.7"
MetricZipCityCountyStateUSA
Jan Avg Low (°F)19.819.819.819.819.8
July Avg High (°F)90.490.490.490.490.4
Annual Precip (in)16.716.716.716.716.7
Safety & Crime
Violent Crimes (per 100k)
TypeZipCityCountyStateUSA
Assault350.5350.5350.5350.5350.5
Murder4.54.54.54.54.5
Robbery63.063.063.063.063.0
Property Crimes (per 100k)
TypeZipCityCountyStateUSA
Burglary348.0348.0348.0348.0348.0
Theft1754.21754.21754.21754.21754.2

Neighborhood Insights

AI-Ready Analysis for Tollgate Valley Gardens

Tollgate Valley Gardens is an accessible entry-point into the CO real estate market located in Aurora. The neighborhood is offering a healthy balance of homeownership and rental opportunities..

Demographically, the area is popular among young professionals and growing families (Median Age: 32.2), creating a unique community atmosphere. With a median household income of $69,719, residents enjoy a quality of life that supports local commerce and community maintenance.
Source: Homendo Network Market Data Analysis (2026).

The real estate market in Tollgate Valley Gardens is currently active. The median home value stands at $367,200, reflecting the desirability of the Aurora area. For investors or those looking to lease, the median rent is approximately $1,438.

According to Homendo Network, the area's inventory turnover (Vacancy Rate: 3.4%) suggests a competitive market where quality homes tend to sell quickly.
Source: Homendo Network Market Data Analysis (2026).

Tollgate Valley Gardens holds a Homendo Safety Score of 92 and an Environmental Quality Score of 90. These metrics are calculated based on local crime statistics per 100k residents and environmental factors like air quality and park density.

Compared to the broader Aurora region, this neighborhood offers a specific balance of security and outdoor accessibility that appeals to safety-conscious buyers.
Source: Homendo Network Market Data Analysis (2026).

The educational landscape in Tollgate Valley Gardens is rated at 82 on the Homendo Index. Located within the Arapahoe County jurisdiction, residents have access to a network of public and private institutions. Families often choose this area specifically for access to these educational resources.
Source: Homendo Network Market Data Analysis (2026).
Location
Powered By
Homendo Network

Real Estate Intelligence

For Professionals
Claim This Place ($1/mo)
Local Experts in 80011
Roofcorp Inc
Roofing 5
Safeguard Mortgage
Mortgage Lender 5
Law Firm of Corporon & Katz LLC
Real Estate Attorney 5
WalkScore™
Walk
Car-Dependent
40
Transit
Good Transit
55
Bike
Somewhat Bikeable
45
School Ratings

Check rating and reviews of schools in this area.

View Schools