Property
ActiveResidential
1/22
$1,500,000

5013 BAY SHORE ROAD

Sarasota, FL 34234
3
Beds
3
Baths
2,671
SqFt
0.39
Acres
STELLAR
#A4685711
Updated: Mar 26, 2026, 9:08am

Property Description

Discover the timeless allure of Indian Beach Sapphire Shores, one of Sarasota’s most captivating neighborhoods where history and modern living intertwine seamlessly. Established in the 1920s, this enchanting enclave exudes old-world charm while offering the vibrant lifestyle of a contemporary coastal community. Positioned perfectly between the glistening waters of Sarasota Bay and the bustling energy of downtown Sarasota, this neighborhood is where tranquility meets cultural sophistication. It's no wonder that John and Mable Ringling chose to make this neighborhood their home.
Here in Sapphire Shores, life effortlessly blends outdoor beauty with unmatched convenience. Just beyond your doorstep, the iconic John and Mable Ringling Museum invites you to explore world-class art, history, and the grandeur of John and Mable's iconic home, the Ca’ d’Zan mansion—a Mediterranean Revival masterpiece that embodies the area’s rich heritage. This property gives you the rare opportunity to bring the home back to its mid-century grandeur, or build anew, the home of your dreams, in the most iconic neighborhood in Sarasota. This property has been previewed by home builders and contractors, if you would like to speak with them regarding the home's possible potential. Imagine starting your day with a serene walk along the bayfront at Sapphire Shores Park or Indian Beach Bayfront Park, where panoramic water views and golden sunsets create a picture-perfect backdrop or grab a cup of coffee and take a stroll up to the Ringling Museum and gaze at their famed banyan trees.
This home is a major rehab with great character and good bones set on a lush .39 acre lot, with plenty of room for a pool. Stroll along the picturesque, tree-canopied Bay Shore Road, where majestic live oaks, sprawling banyans, and stately royal palms provide dappled shade. Despite its proximity to bustling U.S. 41, the area feels like an oasis, inviting you to explore its eminently walkable streets.
Indian Beach Sapphire Shores also boasts proximity to Sarasota's cultural gems, including theaters, galleries, and fine dining, while serene beaches like Lido Key and Longboat Key beckon just minutes away. Adding to the neighborhood’s vibrancy are renowned institutions like New College, USF Sarasota-Manatee, and the Ringling College of Art and Design, infusing the community with creativity and intellectual energy.
More than just a place to live, Indian Beach/Sapphire Shores offers a lifestyle of elegance, inspiration, and connection. Whether you’re drawn by its historic character, its artistic pulse, or the sheer beauty of Sarasota Bay, you’ll find yourself immersed in a neighborhood that truly has it all. Welcome to a place where every day feels extraordinary.
Launch 3D Virtual Tour
Opens in a new window
Included Appliances
None

Property Details

Interior
Bathrooms Total Decimal
2.5
Building Area Total
3301
Cooling
Central Air
Flooring
Other
Furnished
Unfurnished
Heating
Central
Interior Features
Other
Living Area
2671
Rooms Total
6
Construction
Building Area Source
Public Records
Building Area Units
Square Feet
Construction Materials
BlockConcreteStuccoWood FrameWood Siding
Direction Faces
East
Foundation Details
Slab
Levels
Two
Living Area Source
Public Records
Living Area Units
Square Feet
Property Condition
Fixer
Roof
ConcreteTile
Stories Total
2
Year Built
1951
Site & Exterior
Exterior Features
Private Yard
Flood Zone Code
X
I D X Participation
Yes
Lot Features
Corner LotHistoric DistrictIn CountyLevel
Lot Size Acres
0.39
Lot Size Area
16990
Lot Size Square Feet
16990
Lot Size Units
Square Feet
Public Survey Range
17E
Public Survey Section
01
Road Responsibility
Public Maintained Road
Road Surface Type
Asphalt
Sewer
Public Sewer
Total Acreage
1/4 to less than 1/2
Utilities
Cable AvailableElectricity ConnectedPublicSewer Connected
Vegetation
Mature LandscapingOak Trees
Water Source
Public
Zoning
RSF2
Zoning Compatible
Yes
Financials
Calculated List Price By Calculated Sq Ft
561.59
Contract Status Change Date
2026-03-25
Current Price
1500000
Feed Types
BBO
Lease Considered
Yes
Minimum Lease
1 Month
Owner Name
BAYSHORE LAND LLC (TE)
Ownership
Fee Simple
Parcel Number
2001120042
Public Survey Township
36S
Tax Annual Amount
9541.64
Tax Block
C
Tax Book Number
773-1062
Tax Legal Description
LOTS 21 & 22 BLK C SAPPHIRE SHORES ORI 2000092762
Tax Lot
21
Tax Year
2025

Neighborhood & Lifestyle

Community & Association
Additional Lease Restrictions
Buyer to confirm lease restrictions with Sarasota County.
M L S Area Major
34234 - Sarasota
S W Subdiv Community Name
Sapphire Shores
Subdivision Name
SAPPHIRE SHORES
Schools
Ratings
Elementary
Emma E. Booker Elementary
Middle
Booker Middle
High
Booker High
Listing provided courtesy of STELLAR via IDX. Updated: Mar 26, 2026, 9:08am.
Worth Fiers III

Listing Agent

COMPASS FLORIDA LLC

Call Agent