Property Description

Located in Sarasota’s established West of Trail neighborhood, this gated and fenced 1920 Craftsman residence offers a rare double lot and a guest cottage. Originally constructed in 1920 and comprehensively renovated in 2025 and 2026, the property preserves its architectural character while integrating modern systems, finishes and upgrades including all impact windows and doors. Spanning 3,609 total square feet, the estate is designed for privacy and flexibility. The main residence includes three bedrooms and two and one-half baths. The primary suite is positioned on the main level with direct access to the pool and courtyard, along with a spacious walk-in closet. Large-format porcelain block flooring extends throughout, complemented by updated lighting and professionally curated design elements introduced during the full vintage renovation. The kitchen supports both daily living and entertaining, anchored by a substantial island with quartz countertops, new appliances and a natural gas five-burner range. A dining nook overlooks the pool and courtyard, while adjacent living and lounge areas create seamless gathering spaces. Outdoor living centers around a private courtyard featuring a heated saltwater pool and spa with rock fountain feature, outdoor kitchen, multiple balconies and sitting areas, a sweeping front porch and the landscape lighting is strategically set among the mature Florida landscaping. A custom-built treehouse fort and chicken coop contribute additional character to the grounds. A detached, air-conditioned two-car garage includes a self-contained guest cottage above with one bedroom, office and one bath, with additional covered parking offering flexibility for extended family, guests or potential rental income. Conveniently located near Hillview Street dining and shopping, Morton’s market, the bayfront, Downtown Sarasota and Southside Elementary School, this property combines preserved Craftsman architecture with modern livability in one of Sarasota’s most desirable in-town locations. Can be sold furnished.

Launch 3D Virtual Tour

Opens in a new window

Included Appliances

Built-In OvenConvection OvenDishwasherDisposalExhaust FanGas Water HeaterMicrowaveRangeRange HoodRefrigerator

Property Details

Highlights

View

Yes

Interior

Additional Rooms

AtticBonus RoomDen/Library/OfficeFormal Dining Room SeparateFormal Living Room SeparateInside UtilityStorage Rooms

Appliances

Built-In OvenConvection OvenDishwasherDisposalExhaust FanGas Water HeaterMicrowaveRangeRange HoodRefrigerator

Bathrooms Total Decimal

3.5

Building Area Total

3609

Cooling

Central Air

Flooring

OtherPorcelain Tile

Furnished

Unfurnished

Heating

CentralElectric

Interior Features

Built-in FeaturesEating Space In KitchenOtherPrimary Bedroom Main FloorSolid Wood CabinetsSplit BedroomStone CountersThermostatWalk-In Closet(s)Window Treatments

Laundry Features

InsideLaundry Room

Living Area

2545

Rooms Total

9

Security Features

Security GateSmoke Detector(s)

Window Features

BlindsInsulated WindowsWindow Treatments

Construction

Architectural Style

Craftsman

Building Area Source

Public Records

Building Area Units

Square Feet

Construction Materials

Wood Siding

Direction Faces

West

Foundation Details

Pillar/Post/Pier

Levels

Two

Living Area Source

Public Records

Living Area Units

Square Feet

Roof

Metal

Year Built

1920

Site & Exterior

Covered Spaces

2

Exterior Features

BalconyCourtyardIrrigation SystemLightingOutdoor Grill

Fencing

Fenced

Flood Zone Code

X

Garage Spaces

2

I D X Participation

Yes

Lot Features

Corner LotLandscaped

Lot Size Acres

0.28

Lot Size Area

12158

Lot Size Dimensions

140 x 92

Lot Size Square Feet

12158

Lot Size Units

Square Feet

Other Structures

Guest HouseOtherOutdoor KitchenShed(s)Storage

Patio And Porch Features

CoveredDeckFront PorchOtherPorchSide Porch

Pool Features

DeckGuniteHeatedSalt Water

Public Survey Range

18

Public Survey Section

30

Road Frontage Type

Street Paved

Road Responsibility

Public Maintained Road

Road Surface Type

PavedAsphalt

Sewer

Public Sewer

Spa Features

HeatedIn Ground

Total Acreage

1/4 to less than 1/2

Utilities

BB/HS Internet AvailableElectricity ConnectedNatural Gas ConnectedSewer ConnectedSprinkler WellStreet LightsWater Connected

Vegetation

Mature LandscapingOak TreesTrees/Landscaped

View

Trees/Woods

Water Source

Well

Zoning

RSF2

Zoning Compatible

Yes

Financials

Calculated List Price By Calculated Sq Ft

1473.48

Contract Status Change Date

2026-02-23

Current Price

3750000

Feed Types

BBO

Lease Considered

Yes

Minimum Lease

1 Week

Ownership

Fee Simple

Parcel Number

2037150060

Public Survey Township

36

Tax Annual Amount

6507

Tax Legal Description

BEG AT NE COR OF INTRS OF ORANGE AVE & HYDE PARK ST TH N 153.5 FT TH S-89-33-E 140 FT TH S 153.5 FT TH N-89-33-W 140 FT TO POB, LESS COM AT NE COR OF INTRS OF ORANGE AVE & HYDE PARK ST TH N 83 FT FOR

Tax Year

2025

Neighborhood & Lifestyle

Community & Association

Additional Lease Restrictions

City of Sarasota

M L S Area Major

34239 - Sarasota/Pinecraft

Pet Size

Extra Large (101+ Lbs.)

Pets Allowed

Yes

S W Subdiv Community Name

Not Applicable

Schools

Ratings

Elementary

Southside Elementary

Middle

Brookside Middle

High

Sarasota High

Listing provided courtesy of STELLAR via IDX. Updated: May 31, 2026, 5:53pm.

1611 HYDE PARK STREET

1611 HYDE PARK STREET

Property Description

Property Details

Highlights

Interior

Construction

Site & Exterior

Financials

Neighborhood & Lifestyle

Community & Association

Schools

Lori Carey, LLC

$20

$200

Your Digital HQ

Growth Tools

$100 Voucher

1611 HYDE PARK STREET

1611 HYDE PARK STREET

Property Description

Property Details

Highlights

Interior

Construction

Site & Exterior

Financials

Neighborhood & Lifestyle

Community & Association

Schools

Lori Carey, LLC