Property Description

In the "heart" of the most popular West of Trail neighborhood, step into a rare piece of Sarasota history just a short stroll to Southside Village restaurants and shops, downtown and 2 blocks to Sarasota Memorial Hospital. Behind a classic white picket fence, this 1926 home welcomes you with a generous yard framed by mature landscaping and colorful gardens. A cozy front porch sets the tone for your entrance into timeless architectural details which blend seamlessly with modern updates. Wood floors run throughout the living areas with natural light pouring in through numerous windows. Tall ceilings are complimented by original wood trim. All the details we love in an older home yet with many updates. The main home offers 2,575 sq ft thoughtfully laid out for everyday living and entertaining. The main level features multiple living spaces, separate dining room, a guest bedroom, a dedicated office and laundry room. Upstairs, the spacious owner's suite plus an additional bedroom with ensuite bathroom provide comfort and privacy. The remodeled kitchen is beautifully appointed with granite counters and custom cabinetry AND....a charming 306 sf studio-style guest cottage that has its own entrance and patio. COME SEE THIS BEAUTY, you will LOVE it.

Launch 3D Virtual Tour

Opens in a new window

Included Appliances

DishwasherDryerElectric Water HeaterExhaust FanMicrowaveRangeRange HoodRefrigeratorWasher

Property Details

Highlights

View

Yes

Interior

Additional Rooms

Den/Library/OfficeFamily RoomFormal Dining Room SeparateFormal Living Room Separate

Appliances

DishwasherDryerElectric Water HeaterExhaust FanMicrowaveRangeRange HoodRefrigeratorWasher

Bathrooms Total Decimal

5

Building Area Total

3846

Cooling

Central Air

Fireplace Features

Living RoomWood Burning

Flooring

TileHardwood

Furnished

Unfurnished

Heating

CentralElectric

Interior Features

Ceiling Fan(s)Eating Space In KitchenPrimaryBedroom UpstairsSplit BedroomStone CountersWalk-In Closet(s)

Laundry Features

InsideLaundry Room

Living Area

2881

Rooms Total

13

Construction

Architectural Style

BungalowCottage

Building Area Source

Public Records

Building Area Units

Square Feet

Construction Materials

HardiPlank TypeWood Frame (FSC Certified)Wood Siding

Direction Faces

South

Foundation Details

Crawlspace

Levels

Two

Living Area Source

Public Records

Living Area Units

Square Feet

Num Timesper Year

52

Property Condition

Completed

Roof

Metal

Stories Total

2

Year Built

1926

Site & Exterior

Exterior Features

Awning(s)French DoorsGardenPrivate Yard

Fencing

Wood

Flood Zone Code

X

I D X Participation

Yes

Lot Features

City LotIn CountyLevelNear Public Transit

Lot Size Acres

0.25

Lot Size Area

10688

Lot Size Square Feet

10688

Lot Size Units

Square Feet

Number Of Wells

Yes

Open Parking

Yes

Other Structures

Guest HouseStorage

Parking Features

DrivewayOff Street

Patio And Porch Features

CoveredFront PorchPatioRear PorchScreened

Public Survey Range

18E

Public Survey Section

30

Road Frontage Type

Street Paved

Road Responsibility

Public Maintained Road

Road Surface Type

Paved

Sewer

Public Sewer

Total Acreage

1/4 to less than 1/2

Utilities

BB/HS Internet AvailableCable ConnectedElectricity ConnectedNatural Gas ConnectedSewer ConnectedStreet LightsWater Connected

Vegetation

Mature LandscapingTrees/Landscaped

View

Garden

Water Source

Public

Zoning

RSF2

Zoning Compatible

Yes

Financials

Calculated List Price By Calculated Sq Ft

518.92

Contract Status Change Date

2026-02-20

Current Price

1495000

Feed Types

BBO

Lease Considered

Yes

Minimum Lease

1 Week

Owner Name

ON RECORD

Ownership

Fee Simple

Parcel Number

2037070042

Public Survey Township

36S

Tax Annual Amount

511.59

Tax Block

B

Tax Book Number

1-17

Tax Legal Description

LOT 6 & W 1/2 LOT 5 BLK B MATHENY SUB

Tax Lot

6

Tax Year

2025

Neighborhood & Lifestyle

Community & Association

Community Features

Park

M L S Area Major

34239 - Sarasota/Pinecraft

Pets Allowed

Yes

S W Subdiv Community Name

Matheneys Sub

Subdivision Name

MATHENEYS SUB

Schools

Ratings

Elementary

Southside Elementary

Middle

Brookside Middle

High

Sarasota High

Listing provided courtesy of STELLAR via IDX. Updated: May 4, 2026, 4:23pm.

1751 FLOYD STREET

1751 FLOYD STREET

Property Description

Property Details

Highlights

Interior

Construction

Site & Exterior

Financials

Neighborhood & Lifestyle

Community & Association

Schools

Barbara May

$20

$200

Your Digital HQ

Growth Tools

$100 Voucher

1751 FLOYD STREET

1751 FLOYD STREET

Property Description

Property Details

Highlights

Interior

Construction

Site & Exterior

Financials

Neighborhood & Lifestyle

Community & Association

Schools

Barbara May