545 Tregay Street

Step into Silver Plume’s living history with this circa-1880 home—carefully revived after decades of vacancy and updated for everyday comfort. When the current owner purchased the property in 1991, it hadn’t been lived in for roughly 60 years. Between 1991–1996, he undertook a comprehensive remodel to bring the home back to life while honoring its 19th-century character. Inside, you’ll find all the essentials renewed: new drywall, updated electrical, and new water and sewer lines. Sixteen thermal-pane windows brighten the rooms and frame views of this storied mountain town. Major systems are in great shape, too—the combined boiler/water-heater unit was replaced in May 2024, and the roof was installed by Home Depot in 2016. Set on peaceful Tregay Street, the home sits in the heart of historic Silver Plume—an authentic former mining community where Victorian-era architecture and mountain scenery meet. Enjoy sounds of the river just beyond the home. This is a rare opportunity to own a true piece of Colorado history that’s been thoughtfully made livable again.